Skip to content
Top Stories

High Court Rules Government Pay Equity Overhaul Breached Bill of Rights Act

New Zealand News Editorial team · AI-written, reviewed under our editorial standards · · Reading time 9min read · Views 0 ·
Key — The High Court ruled that the coalition Government's Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025 breached the Bill of Rights Act. Justice Paul Radich delivered the judgment on November 19, 2026.

The High Court ruled on November 19, 2026, that the coalition Government's Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025 breached the Bill of Rights Act. Justice Paul Radich delivered the judgment on that date. The court found that the government's overhaul made it more difficult for women to file pay equity claims and cancelled existing claims. This decision impacts the coalition Government and the next Government regarding the implementation of pay equity legislation.

Court Finds Discrimination Against Women

Justice Radich stated that the tightening of the Equal Pay Act discriminated against women and was inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act. The court found that the primary motivation for the changes was financial, not fixing a broken system. Official papers showed the changes were mainly motivated by the cost of settling pay equity claims. The court rejected the unions' argument that the government breached rights by passing the changes without consultation.

The court found that the primary motivation for the changes was financial, not fixing a broken system. Justice Radich noted that official papers showed the changes were mainly motivated by the cost of settling pay equity claims. The court rejected the unions' argument that the government breached rights by passing the changes without consultation. This ruling confirms that the legislative changes were driven by financial concerns rather than systemic reform.

Judgment Does Not Invalidate Law

The judgment does not invalidate the law or restore extinguished claims, but the next government must issue a formal response for parliamentary debate. The Crown retains the right to appeal the decision. The Public Service Association called the ruling a groundbreaking historic decision and demanded the next government restore the original regime without delay. The PSA stated that the government cancelled claims without warning or due democratic process.

Fleur Fitzsimons, PSA national secretary, stated that the government cynically cancelled pay equity claims under the cover of darkness, without warning and without due democratic process. She added that it was an immoral and now an unlawful betrayal and wage theft, plain and simple. Today the court has confirmed what women knew all along, pay equity is a fundamental right and must be upheld.

Unions Challenged Urgency Passage

The Public Service Association was one of five unions that challenged the law change after it was passed under urgency in May 2025. The government's lawyers argued the changes aimed to make the system more robust and sustainable. The PSA stated that the government cancelled claims without warning or due democratic process. The ruling impacts the coalition Government and the next Government regarding the implementation of pay equity legislation.

Fleur Fitzsimons, PSA national secretary, stated that the next Government must now do the right thing by women and restore real pay equity legislation, and the pay equity claims as a priority. The PSA called the ruling a groundbreaking historic decision and demanded the next government restore the original regime without delay. The High Court ruled that the coalition Government's Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025 breached the Bill of Rights Act.

Glossary

  • Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025 — The Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025 is a New Zealand omnibus Act of Parliament that raised the threshold for workers to prove historically undervalued work when making a pay equity claim. The Act amends the Equal Pay Act 1972, the Employment Relations Act 2000 and the Public Service Act 2020.
  • Bill of Rights Act — The New Zealand Bill of Rights Act sets out the civil and political rights of New Zealand citizens against the three branches of government and entities and persons exercising public functions. The Act is not entrenched and in consequence has been amended by Parliament three times since its passage.
  • coalition Government — The coalition Government's Equal Pay Amendment Act 2025 breached the Bill of Rights Act. This decision impacts the coalition Government and the next Government regarding the implementation of pay equity legislation.
  • Crown — The Crown retains the right to appeal the decision. The Crown retains the right to appeal the decision.

This article was written with AI assistance from multiple news reports and is reviewed by our editors under our editorial principles. Editorial Standards · Tips & Contact

How did you like this post?

Comments 0

Be the first to comment

Contact us

← New Zealand News Home
New Zealand News Get new posts by emailSubscribe to receive new content via email. Unsubscribe anytime.
Was this helpful?Share it with friends & social