Experts demand Mixed Member Proportional reform to address parliamentary overhang issues
A group of 46 experts has called for urgent reforms to the Mixed Member Proportional electoral system to prevent undemocratic election outcomes. The experts signed an open letter titled "Keep the 'P' in MMP" on November 18, 2026, to address issues arising from parliamentary overhang. Initial election results indicate that the total parliamentary overhang has reached 11 seats.
Parliamentary overhang details
The current parliamentary composition shows a significant discrepancy between party vote entitlements and seat totals. The National Party holds seven overhang seats, which resulted from strong performance in individual electorates despite a decline in its party vote. Te Pāti Māori holds four overhang seats, following a campaign to expand influence beyond its party vote entitlement. Together, these 11 seats constitute the total indicated parliamentary overhang.
The experts warned that the current overhang could lead to decreased public trust and disillusionment in democracy. Andrew Geddis, one of the leaders of the open letter, stated that the overhang could result in a majority of seats being held by parties that received fewer votes than others. Max Rashbrooke, also a leader of the letter, stated that the current overhang is not how people want MMP to function and could lead to an arms race in future elections.
Proposed electoral reforms
The open letter argues that the current overhang risks a scenario where three parties hold a majority of seats despite receiving fewer votes than other parties. To address these systemic issues, the 46 experts suggest establishing a dedicated select committee. This committee would be tasked with addressing the overhang issue and implementing long-term solutions to ensure the electoral system remains fair.
The movement for reform highlights concerns regarding the stability and fairness of the Mixed Member Proportional system. The experts emphasized that the current structure allows for outcomes that may not reflect the proportional intent of the voting population. By calling for a formal select committee, the signatories aim to move the debate from political speculation to structured legislative reform.
Historical context of electoral systems
The push for reform follows historical precedents that shaped the current electoral landscape. The 1978 and 1981 elections resulted in National governments despite the Labour Party winning more votes. These specific outcomes served as a primary driver for the transition to the Mixed Member Proportional system to ensure proportionality.
The current 11-seat overhang represents a significant challenge to the democratic principles the system was designed to uphold. As the political landscape adjusts to these election results, the call from experts like Andrew Geddis, Lara Greaves, and Max Rashbrooke underscores the necessity of maintaining the integrity of the proportional representation component of the electoral system.
Glossary
- National Party — The National Party is a centre-right political party in New Zealand. It is one of two major parties that dominate contemporary New Zealand politics.
- Te Pāti Māori — Te Pāti Māori is a political party in New Zealand.
- select committee — A select committee is a body that can be tasked with addressing specific issues and implementing long-term solutions. It is used to move debates from political speculation to structured legislative reform.
This article was written with AI assistance from multiple news reports and is reviewed by our editors under our editorial principles. Editorial Standards · Tips & Contact
Comments 0